<body><script type="text/javascript"> function setAttributeOnload(object, attribute, val) { if(window.addEventListener) { window.addEventListener('load', function(){ object[attribute] = val; }, false); } else { window.attachEvent('onload', function(){ object[attribute] = val; }); } } </script> <div id="navbar-iframe-container"></div> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://apis.google.com/js/platform.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> gapi.load("gapi.iframes:gapi.iframes.style.bubble", function() { if (gapi.iframes && gapi.iframes.getContext) { gapi.iframes.getContext().openChild({ url: 'https://www.blogger.com/navbar/29316727?origin\x3dhttp://courtingthemystery.blogspot.com', where: document.getElementById("navbar-iframe-container"), id: "navbar-iframe" }); } }); </script>

Patristic Abbreviations: Part 2


Saturday, March 28, 2009.

The abbreviations and CPG numbers for Origen and Cyril of Alexandria are finished. They should be online at FourthCentury.com in the next few days.

[Update]
The abbreviations are now available. Origen. Cyril of Alexandria.

Labels: ,



Patristic Abbreviations: Part 1


Sunday, February 22, 2009.


The first part of the Patristic Abbreviations Project is now online. Abbreviations and Clavis Patrum Graecorum numbers for the works of Athanasius are available at www.fourthcentury.com.

I've started working on abbreviations for Origen. I'll let you know when they are finished.

Labels: ,



Patristic Abbreviations: Athanasius


Thursday, February 12, 2009.


Authentic and Spurious Works of Athanasius of Alexandria

Abbrevations according to G. W. H. Lampe, A Patristic Greek Lexicon, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1961. Lampe uses † to denote works of doubtful authorship and ‡ to denote spurious works. For more recent judgements regarding the authenticity of various works, see Timothy Barnes, Athanasius and Constantius: Theology and Politics in the Constantinian Empire (1993) and David Brakke, ‘The Authenticity of the Ascetic Athanasiana,’ Orientalia 63 (1994).

apol. Const. apologia ad Constantium
apol. sec. apologia (secunda) contra Arianos
Ar. 1-3 orationes tres adversus Arianos
decr. de decretis Nicaenae
Dion. de sententia Dionysii
ep. Adelph. epistula ad Adelphium
ep. Aeg. Lib. epistula ad episcopos Aegypti et Libyae
ep. Afr. epistula ad Afros episcopos
ep. Amun. epistula ad Amunem
ep. Drac. epistula ad Dracontium
ep. encycl. epistula encyclica
ep. Epict. epistula ad Epictetum
ep. fest. epistularum festivalium fragmenta
ep. fest. 39 epistula festivalis trecesima nona
ep. Jo. et Ant. epistula ad Joannem et Antiochum
ep. Jov. epistula ad Jovianum
ep. Marcell. epistula ad Marcellinum
ep. Max. epistula ad Maximum
ep. mon. epistula ad monachos
ep. mort. Ar. epistula ad Serapionem de morte Arii
ep. Ors. 1-2 epistulae ad Orsisium
ep. Pall. epistula ad Palladium
ep. Rufin. epistula ad Rufinianum
ep. Serap. 1-4 epistulae ad Serapionem
fr. Job fragmenta in Job
exp. Ps. expositio in Pss.
fr. Pss. comm. fragmenta commentarii in Pss.
fr. Cant. fragmenta in Cant.
hom. in Mt. 11:27 homilia in illud
† fr. Mt. fragmenta in Mt.
fr. Lc. fragmenta in Lc.
† exp. fid. expositio fidei
† fr. fragmenta varia
fug. apologia de fuga sua
gent. contra gentes
h. Ar. historia Arianorum ad monachos
h. Ar. ep. ad historiam Arianorum ad monachos epistula
inc. de incarnatione
inc. et c. Ar. de incarnatione et contra Arianos
narr. fug. narratio ad Ammonium episcopum de fuga
syn. epistula de synodis Arimini et Seleuciae
tom. tomus ad Antiochenos
v. Anton. vita Antonii
virg. de virginitate
‡ annunt. homilia in annuntiationem deiparae
‡ Apoll. 1-2 de incarnatione contra Apollinarem
‡ Ar. 4 oratio quarta contra Arianos
‡ ascens. homilia in assumptionem domini
‡ caec. homilia in caecum a nativitate
‡ comm. essent. de communi essentia Patris et Filii et Spiritus sancti
‡ confut. confutatio quarundam propositionum
‡ corp. de corpore et anima
‡ def. liber de definitionibus
‡ desc. BMV homilia de descriptione deiparae
‡ diab. homilia in diabolum
‡ dial. Trin. 1-5 de Trinitate dialogi
‡ disp. disputatio cum Ario in synodo
‡ doct. Ant. doctrina ad Antiochum ducem
‡ doct. mon. doctrina ad monachos
‡ ep. Cast. 1-2 epistulae ad Castorem
‡ ep. cath. epistula catholica
‡ ep. Lib. epistula ad Liberium
‡ ep. Pers. epistula ad episcopum Persarum
‡ fr. Ps. fragmenta in Pss.
‡ hom. in Mt. 21:2 homilia in illud.
‡ hom. in Mt. 21:9 homilia in illud.
‡ hom. in Lc. 19:36 homilia in illud.
‡ fr. in 1 Cor. 7:1 fragmentum in illud.
‡ fr. in 2 Cor. 12:2 fragmentum in illud.
‡ fr. in 2 Cor. 12:7 fragmentum in illud.
‡ exhort. sermo exhortatorius
‡ haer. sermo contra omnes haereses
‡ imag. fragmentum sermonis de sacris imaginibus
‡ imag. Beryt. sermo in imaginem Berytensem
‡ inst. mon. vitae monasticae institutio
‡ interpr. interpretatio symboli
‡ Jov. ad imperatorem Jovianum
‡ Lat. sermo contra Latinos
‡ Maced. dial. 1-2 contra Macedonianos dialogi
‡ Melch. historia de Melchisedech
‡ nativ. Chr. homilia in nativitate Christi
‡ nativ. Jo. Bapt. homilia in nativitate praecursoris
‡ Novat. contra Novatianos fragmenta
‡ occurs. homilia in occursum Domini
‡ palm. homilia in ramos palmarum
‡ parasc. sermo in passionem domini in parasceve
‡ pasch. 1-2 sermones in pascha
‡ pass. homilia de passione et cruce domini
‡ pat. sermo de patientia
‡ poenit. can. canones poenitentiales
‡ polit. syntagma ad quemdam politicum
‡ prod. Jud. homilia in proditionem Judae
‡ proph. homilia in patres et prophetas
‡ qu. al. 1-20 quaestiones aliae
‡ qu. Ant. 1-137 quaestiones ad Antiochum
‡ qu.ev. 1-36 in evangelia
‡ qu. script. 1-130 quaestiones scripturas
‡ ref. refutatio hypocrisis
‡ renunt. sermo pro iis qui saeculo renuntiarunt
‡ sabb. de sabbatis et circumcisione
‡ Sabell. contra Sabellianos
‡ sem. homilia de semente
‡ serm. Ant. sermo ad Antiochum ducem
‡ serm. fid. sermo major de fide
‡ symb. symbolum ‘Quicumque’ seu Athanasianum dictum
‡ synops. synopsis sacrae scripturae
‡ syntag. syntagma doctrinae admonachos
‡ templ. commentarius de templo Athanarum
‡ theopasch. contra theopaschitas
‡ Trin. de Trinitate
‡ v. Syncl. vita Syncleticae

Labels: , ,



Patristic Abbreviations - A New Project


Thursday, February 12, 2009.


While writing on various Patristic sources, I have often wished that there was a way to quickly track down the standard abbreviations for these works. Most journals and monographs follow the abbreviations in Lampe's Patristic Greek Lexicon, but this volume is too expensive to own and too big to carry around. To partially fill this gap I have created a table listing Lampe's abbreviations for the entire Athanasiana. (See the post above.) I have also decided to begin digitising the rest of these abbreviations.

Dr. Glen Thompson has kindly agreed to host this list, and any others that may follow, at www.fourthcentury.com. I will keep you updated as the project moves ahead. If anyone would like to assist with digitising these abbreviations, please let me know. This is a huge project, and it may not be completed without assistance!

Labels: ,



Origen Gives Us Hope for the Road Ahead:


Friday, January 09, 2009.


“It is far better ‘to die in the wilderness’ than ‘to serve the Egyptians.’ For he who dies in the wilderness, for the very reason that he has been separated from the Egyptians and has departed from ‘the rulers of darkness’ and from the power of Satan, has a certain perfection even if he was not able to arrive at completion. For it is better for one seeking the perfect life to die on the way than not to set out to seek perfection.” Ex Hom 5 p.281-2

The idea of one's trajectory is important to Origen. One ought to strive for perfection (which, in this life consists of attaining the virtues and an invicible faith), but if one does not reach this state, all may not be lost. In the Greek fragments of his Commentary on Romans, Origen emphasizes very clearly that our salvation is dependent upon grace—for even living faith (the sort that bears fruit) is a gift of God.

Labels: , ,



A Living Tradition of Holiness


Sunday, January 04, 2009.


Fr. Stephen Freeman posted a link to an interesting video on ascetics living in Romania. It's about 10 minutes long but is worth watching. The last interview is the most important. At times he echoes Clement of Alexandria, Origen, and early eastern ascetics. Indeed, he appears to represent a living tradition of holiness. ‘Humility, humility, and again, humility!’



The word of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God. For it is written,
‘I will destroy the wisdom of the wise,
and the discernment of the discerning I will thwart.’
Where is the one who is wise? Where is the scribe? Where is the debater of this age? Has not God made foolish the wisdom of the world? For since, in the wisdom of God, the world did not know God through wisdom, God decided, through the foolishness of our proclamation, to save those who believe. For Jews demand signs and Greeks desire wisdom, but we proclaim Christ crucified, a stumbling-block to Jews and foolishness to Gentiles, but to those who are the called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God. For God's foolishness is wiser than human wisdom, and God's weakness is stronger than human strength.

Consider your own call, brothers and sisters: not many of you were wise by human standards, not many were powerful, not many were of noble birth. But God chose what is foolish in the world to shame the wise; God chose what is weak in the world to shame the strong; God chose what is low and despised in the world, things that are not, to reduce to nothing things that are, so that no one might boast in the presence of God. He is the source of your life in Christ Jesus, who became for us wisdom from God, and righteousness and sanctification and redemption, in order that, as it is written, ‘Let the one who boasts, boast in the Lord.’

1 Cor 1:18-31

Labels: , ,



An Introductory Textbook to Syriac


Saturday, January 03, 2009.


For anyone interested in learning Syriac, Stephen Shoemaker from the University of Oregon has published an excellent review of Wheeler Thackston's Introduction to Syriac. Shoemaker clearly indicates the weaknesses of the text, but also explains why Thackston's text is the best of its kind. I'm going to be working with Thackston's text soon, so I'll try to blog my experiences with it too. Shoemaker's article is available in: Hugoye Journal of Syriac Studies.

Labels: , ,



Expand Your Vocabulary


Monday, December 29, 2008.


As I read I try to build my vocabulary by noting particularly effective, unusual, or vivid words. However, today I stumbled upon a few GRE word lists that might also help. The lists are available for review at: http://www.postech.ac.kr.

Labels: ,



Glory to God for All Things


Friday, December 26, 2008.


The Greek Fathers are sometimes accused of overemphasising the role of human beings in the divine life. Although these Fathers insist that people do have a role to play in their redemption, most teach that this role is altogether very small and indeed almost inconsequential when compared to that of God. St. John Chrysostom expresses this relationship well, though his perspective is by no means unique.

“Consider how [Jesus Christ] teaches us to be humble, by making us see that our virtue does not depend on our work alone but on grace from on high. He commands each of the faithful who prays to do so universally, for the whole world. For he did not say “thy will be done in me or in us,” but “on earth,” the whole earth, so that error may be banished from it, truth take root in it, all vice be destroyed on it, virtue flourish on it, and earth no longer differ from heaven.”


St. John Chrysostom on the Lord's Prayer


On a side note, the the title of this post, which also comes from Chrysostom, is the name of an excellent blog by an Eastern Orthodox priest in the United States: “Glory to God for All Things”.

Labels: , ,



Chronological Chart of Athanasius' Works


Wednesday, December 03, 2008.


The contributors at FourthCentury.com have compiled an excellent chart outlining the chronology of Athanasius' writings. The chart primarily follows the dates given by Timothy D. Barnes (see Athanasius and Constantius: Theology and Politics in the Constantinian Empire). Barnes is an expert in these matters, and he proposes dates that are sound though sometimes disputable. The chart is available at: www.fourthcentury.com.

Labels: , ,



Back from France


Friday, November 21, 2008.


I apologise for the lack of updates recently. I was in France for a few days. The cost of flights from the UK to the continent is actually quite decent, which makes travelling an almost affordable part of studying overseas.

I combined two of my favourite pictures into a desktop wallpaper.


Labels:



Patristics Seminar: Paper #3


Monday, November 10, 2008.


Moses as Exemplar Among Early Christian Readers
by Pak-Wah Lai, PhD research student at Durham University
6 November, 2008

Last week Mr. Pak-Wah Lai presented a paper on the use of Moses as an exemplar in early Christian writers. Lai opened by sharing some contemporary views of Moses. Drawing on popular book titles, Lai suggested that Moses is often interpreted according to the values and problems of a culture.

Lai then summarised the Jewish and Greek traditions that helped shape later Christian descriptions of Moses. One of the most interesting points here concerned ancient Greek biographies. In Greek biographical literature lives are often shaped according to the biographical paradigm of i) origins, ii) upbringing, iii) and deeds. In the Jewish tradition, Moses is often portrayed as the servant of God, the friend of God, a man of prayer, a follower of the Law, and as a prophet. One of the most common and important motifs is Moses as the faithful servant of God. Lai also noted that Moses is remembered in the OT according to his four offices: leader, and law-giver, prophet, and priest. In Second Temple literature, Moses was re-conceived as the archetypal figure or model for people to pattern their life after, and for certain vocations to model (e.g. prophets, leaders, philosopher kings). Moses also becomes the exemplary figure who embodies certain virtues.

After discussing Moses in Philo, Lai proceeded to discuss Moses in the New Testament and Apostolic era. Lai noted that the first Christians appear to have maintained the traditional motifs of Moses (e.g. as archetypal leader). But Moses was also transformed in light of the Christ event. Christ is now the superior of the two, and Moses is often recast as a Christian prophet and allegorically interpreted as a type of Christ. The Mosaic writings were also allegorically interpreted as witnesses anticipating Christ.

Next, Lai examined the images of Moses in Justin Matyr, Clement of Alexandria, Origen, the Cappadocian Fathers, and John Chrysostom. Justin Martyr portrays Moses as a prophet of Christ, the allegorist of Christ, and the philosopher par excellance. Clement of Alexandria envisions Moses as one who was instructed by Christ, and who instructs the Jews in preparation for Christ. Moses is the exemplary student of Christ. Origen assumes the portrait of Moses as allegorist and gives great weight to the spiritual meaning of Moses’ writings. Moses is also envisioned as an example of one who prays rightly.

In the fourth century the Cappadocian Fathers continued to use Moses as a Christian exemplar. Basil of Caesarea provides a biography of Moses’ life that is clearly drawn from earlier biographies of Moses, and which stresses Moses’ origins, upbringing, deeds. Like Clement of Alexandria, Moses leads a philosophic life and attains the vision of God so far as is possible. This vision of God is only possible because it has been granted by God. Moses is also a type of Christ: Moses like Christ is a mediator between God and man. For Gregory of Nazianzus, Moses is an example of how to do theological inquiry. Moses is also a measure against which Christian bishops can be compared, for he is the ideal leader. For Gregory of Nyssa, Moses is the exemplary Christian mystic.

Finally, Pak-Wah focused on the subject in John Chrysostom. Chrysostom largely adopts traditional views (e.g. Moses as a prophet of Christ). Chrysostom also compares Moses with Paul as a teacher of Christ, though Paul is greater than Moses. Chrysostom stresses Moses’ poor origins, though he inverts the usual paradigm. Moses had poor origins but still became faithful to God. Pak-Wah used these and other examples to demonstrate that Chrysostom presents Moses as the archetypal Christian and the exemplary man of prayer.

From this survey, Lai concluded that the early Chrisitans affirmed the Mosaic and biographical traditions which they had inherited, but that they also shaped the image of Moses into one which resembled themselves and their values. In this way, the early Christians appropriated these traditions for their contemporary issues, painting Moses an exemplary figure relevant to their own contexts.

In 60 minutes Lai managed to offer accurate analyses of a wide time period. His presentation was clear and his summaries insightful.

Labels: , ,



Patristics Carnival 17


Thursday, November 06, 2008.


Weekend Fisher has posted Patristics Carnival 17. This carnival, like those before it, highlights recent bloggings on the Church Fathers, putting links to them on a single page. Click here to visit the Patristics Carnival.

Labels: ,



Richard B. Hays: Jesus as the God of Israel in Mark's Gospel


Tuesday, November 04, 2008.


Last night I had the pleasure of hearing Richard B. Hays present a stimulating paper on Jesus' divine identity as the God of Israel in the Gospel According to Mark. Nijay Gupta's blog has a good summary of the paper. Click here to read more.

Labels: ,



An Introduction to Deification / Theosis


Monday, November 03, 2008.


A few days ago I stumbled upon a blog with an interesting entry on Athanasius. In the entry, the blogger reported his experiences of reading Athanasius' On the Incarnation of the Word. He was struck by the same thing that I was the first time I read it: 'God became man that man might become God.' To the ears of most Protestants who have not heard of deification/theosis, this phrase sounds preposterous—perhaps even blasphemous.

When I first read this, I was fortunate enough to have a professor with whom I could discuss it. He helped put the phrase in its context and explain what Athanasius and other Fathers meant by this language. He told me that I had come across a completely different vision of salvation, which is called deification or theosis.

Several years later, Professor Andrew Louth added further details: deification is not an element of salvation; salvation is an element of deification, for deification encompasses salvation. For Fathers such as St. Irenaeus, salvation marks a return or restoration of humanity to its original state of innocence, but deification is the means by which human beings progress into something far beyond mere innocence. Deification marks the maturation of the person into the full image and likeness of God, which is expressed by love, guided by reason, and empowered by divine grace and communion.

I don't know if this blogger has access to similar people, so I wrote a brief introductory explanation of deification / theosis. I have posted it below, if you are interested:


...What you have highlighted is an expression of Athanasius' doctrine of deification (which St. Gregory of Nazianzus later named 'theosis'). Athanasius, like many others before him (including Irenaeus), affirms that God truly became man, lived, died, and was raised from the dead, not only to save humanity from sin and death (which have a lot to do with ontology and going out of existence—not merely with what Prostestants might describe as 'justice'), but also to restore human beings to the image and likeness of God.

As I'm sure you noticed, Athanasius is very careful to distinguish between the created and the Creator. Athanasius teaches that the final goal of human life is to be deified, but this deification is ultimately about being conformed to the divine image and likeness (which includes knowledge and communion with God, along with holiness, obedience, and love, among other things). For Athanasius, and Irenaeus, we are made 'gods' by the Son and Holy Spirit, but even then we remain creatures—we are never 'God' in the same way that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are 'God', for we remain dependent upon God for our existence and have been created by God, whereas the Triune God is eternal and uncreated.

One of the central ways that deification is described is by the language of participation. Irenaeus and Athanasius teach that in the incarnation human nature itself was deified 'in Christ'. Yet, this deification remains to be realised in us. We must choose to 'opt in' to it, by following God and allowing His Spirit to sanctify us, as we strive to love and obey Him, and become like the Logos, i.e. live according to reason. When we begin to live in this way, we begin to participate in the life of God, and begin moving towards deification.


For an excellent survey of the history of the doctrine, see Norman Russell, The Doctrine of Deification in the Greek Patristic Tradition, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004.

Labels: ,



Patristics Seminar: Paper #1


Saturday, November 01, 2008.


Naming God
by Dr. Krastu Banev, lecturer at Durham University
23 October, 2008

The 2008-9 Durham Patristics Seminar began with a presentation by Dr. Krastu Banev. Banev, who was recently appointed as a lecturer of Greek Patristics at Durham University, gave an insightful paper on the history of the naming of God in the Bible and the Eastern Christian tradition. I found this paper particularly engaging because it highlighted the depth and coherence behind the Orthodox emphasis on the divine name.

Dr. Banev opened by discussing the theme of names in the Bible. In this section he made three main points. First, He argued that a name is linked to the essence it describes. So, for example, Eve is linked to life. A name can also be linked to an event. Because of this connection between a name and the essence or event it describes, to blaspheme against a name is to blaspheme against the person who bears the name. Second, he argued that to change a name is to enter into a new relationship. Abram/Abraham is an example of this phenomenon. Third, he suggested that it is only through names that we can have remembrance. The name, he contended, is also the means by which God remembers us. Names are necessary for our existence because it is by means of our name that we derive our existence from God.

The rest of the paper focused on the history of naming God in the Eastern Church. Dr. Banev quickly summarised the theme in a couple of philosophers and a number of theologians. Here are his observations.
  • Plato: natural / essential view (somewhat similar to the Biblical view).
  • Aristotle: subjective
  • Origen: the name refers to the nature
  • Eunomius: believed he could totally grasp God by the name agennetos.
  • The Cappadocian Fathers: the name does not capture the essence. It gives us the relationship of the persons; it is not the essence.
  • Pseudo-Dionysius: God must be beyond names. Names are symbols of God's acts.
Dr. Banev then summarised the significance of names during the iconoclast controversy. The important point here is that images are linked to the prototype by the name. Uncreated grace and the created are combined. By the divine name we enter into God's presence. Banev also addressed the naming of God in the Hesychast controversy. Here the reality of prayer was affirmed by use of the Jesus prayer. The Hesychasts taught that by invoking the name ('Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God') a human being can really become a temple of God by the Holy Spirit, just as God had formerly dwelt in the Temple by placing His name upon it. Dr. Banev proposed that this marked a return to this Biblical view.

Finally, he discussed the subject in 20th century Russia. In the early 1900's a new movement established itself by teaching that 'the name of God is God himself, and it works miracles.' This movement was known as the 'worshippers of the name,' and they quickly and forcefully took over the largest skete on Mount Athos. In 1912 Russia declared this a heretical teaching. Later, the Russian Pavel Florensky defended the movement and offered a more nuanced perspective: 'The name of God is God himself, but God Himself is not the name.' Florensky wanted to clarify that God is not encompassed by His name. Florensky was exiled for his position, and the perspective of the 'name worshippers' remains a problem in Russia to this day.

Labels: , ,



My writing process


Wednesday, October 22, 2008.


The process of writing is something unique to each of us. Some people go through numerous drafts for everything they write; others seem to get it right the first time. I am still learning about and developing my process. However, I thought I might share a little about my approach, not because it is ideal but because it seems to work for me. I would be interested to hear how others manage the writing process.

I begin by carefully reading through my subject's primary sources at least once, though reading through it multiple times is always best. As I read I take notes, often typing large quotations word-for-word. I find large quotations are much more helpful than short ones because lengthy quotations provide a sense of the argument's context. As I input these quotations I arrange them by category (eg 'Anthropology', 'Cosmology', etc.). After I have read through the text, I like to gain some background by reading through at least a few secondary sources. I find it helpful to read at least one older, 'seminal' work on the subject (eg something written between 1920-1960). Checking through bibliographies is one way to find these works, or at least to locate the 'standard' works. Next, I read through at least one newer book on the subject that has been extremely well received by experts in the field. For Athanasius, for example, Anatolios' Athanasius: The Coherence of His Thought stands as perhaps the most important recent work on the subject, and is therefore essential reading for anyone engaging Athanasius. Additionally, I like to read through journal articles in order to supplement and expand my perspective.

Having said all this, I think it is important not to dedicate too much time to background reading because I want to get my own perspective on the subject written before I become absolutely overwhelmed with the perspectives of others. These other perspectives should not be ignored, but I can engage them and learn from them after I have concretely established my own (tentative) view on the subject through writing. The value of putting my thoughts down in writing before I have read too broadly is that it allows me to record my perspective while it is still fresh in my mind and largely a product of my own engagement with the primary texts. It also means I have a concrete perspective that I can use to dialogue with other secondary sources.

As I prepare to write, I read through my notes, trying to get a sense of how the parts fit together. During this time I often break large categories into subcategories according to the logic of the subject's own perspective. E.g. in Irenaeus' works I might have the broad category of soteriology or deification, and a sub-category of 'recapitulation'. As I read through these notes over and over, I begin to get a sense of the bigger picture. Eventually I write a rough outline of my paper itself. After this, I usually re-categorise my notes according to this outline. Sometimes this involves combining a couple sub-categories; other times it involves creating a new category altogether. Then I begin to write my paper itself, using these categories to texts and to preserve both the big picture and the details of the subject. I usually write sub-section by sub-section. Sometimes it is helpful to write out a short (1/2 page) hand-written outline of the sub-section. This outline usually consists of individual points or sentences that I wish to include, based on the texts themselves. One point might look like: [It is] impossible for man to reform himself into the image [of God] AH 3.18.2. This rough writing forms the basis of the sub-section, and it is a helpful way to quickly record, analyse, organise, and re-organise the flow of my argument without having to worry about grammar and style. Next, I try to write the sub-section itself, using the outline as a guide. When writing in this way, I try to write clearly, though I try not to be too concerned with style. At this stage it is much more important for me to develop my ideas and be careful concerning the details and the arguments.

After finishing this rough draft on the subject, I try put some temporal distance between myself and the paper so I can hopefully approach it with a more critical eye. I also try to re-read the primary source, or at least my notes on it, so I can test where my paper does and does not align with the text itself. After this, I read those secondary sources that I had avoided reading. These processes help refine my perspective. Finally, I revise my paper in order to accommodate these changes and improve the writing itself. It is at this stage that I can say that I have what one might call a first or second draft. Undoubtedly the paper remains imperfect, but at least it should be presentable and ready for later, more mature revision.

Labels: ,



Upcoming UK Conference


Monday, October 20, 2008.


A postgraduate conference, titled 'Interdisciplinarity in Theology and Religion: How to tie knots that will hold', will be hosted by Durham University in January (13–14, 2009). The conference will feature presentations from Rev. Prof. Sarah Coakley (Cambridge) and Prof. Douglas Davies (Durham) as well as student paper sessions. The conference should be a good opportunity for postgraduate students to present their research and collectively converse about integrating interdisciplinary perspectives into the study of theology and religion.

The registration and call for papers are both open.
For more information visit: http://www.itrdurham.com.

Labels:



Durham Patristics Seminar 2008


Friday, October 17, 2008.


Michaelmas 2008

Thursday 23 October
Krastu Banev
Naming God

Thursday 30 October
Kevin Hill
The Spirit of Life: Pneumatology and Deification in St Irenaeus and his Predecessors

Thursday 6 November
Pak Wah Lai
Moses as Exemplar among Early Christian Readers

Thursday 13 November
Jonathan Zecher
Towards a Canonical Reading of the Byzantine Funeral Liturgy: Its History, Development, and Coherence

Thursday 20 and 27 November
Readings from Clement of Alexandria from Whitacre’s Patristic Greek Reader, led by Krastu Banev

Thursday 4 December
David Bradshaw, University of Kentucky
Mind and Heart in Christian East and West

All seminars at 4.15 p.m. in Seminar Room C

(Though intended for postgraduates (both MA and research) interested in Patristic and Byzantine studies, these seminars are open to anyone who is interested in the subjects discussed.)

Labels: , ,



NT Wright's research assistant


Thursday, October 02, 2008.


For those who are interested, N.T. Wright has hired a new research assistant. The position was filled by my good friend Ben Blackwell of 'Dunelm Road' fame. Congratulations Ben. I wish you and Bishop Wright much success.

Be sure to visit Ben's blog (http://dunelm.wordpress.com) and the N.T. Wright page (http://ntwrightpage.com).

Labels:




Blogroll